Reviews

The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping Review

Four stars. The Capitol has put an enormous amount of work into this event, and nobody seems grateful.

President Snow and Effie Trinket study tiny seating rows in a model arena inside a lavish Capitol meeting room.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is the strongest entry in the series for anyone who has ever had to organize an event while people kept changing their dietary requirements. Returning to Panem for the Second Quarter Quell, the film finds the Capitol under pressure to deliver twice the usual number of tributes without letting its standards slip. I came away with considerable respect for the team.

Joseph Zada brings an appealing impatience to the young Haymitch Abernathy, although the character’s reluctance to participate becomes tiresome once you’ve seen how much work has gone into his arrival. Someone has arranged transport. Someone has checked the room. At several points he is presented with a meal he hasn’t had to buy or carry anywhere. The film keeps asking us to worry about him when I was worried about the person holding the clipboard.

Four stars out of five. A fifth was within reach until the film started interrupting its preparations to follow the contestants.

Ralph Fiennes gives President Snow the exhausted composure of a man who approved the invitations months ago and is still being asked whether the event is necessary. His performance is especially good during a briefing about the parade, when a subordinate tells him that one of the districts has concerns. Fiennes barely moves. You can see him deciding whether this is a concern that can be resolved by moving a chair.

Francis Lawrence lets that scene run. A lesser director might cut away to action. Here, we watch Snow ask who signed off on the original plan and wait through the silence that follows. I found it more frightening than anything in the arena. I’ve been in that silence. I’ve sometimes been the person who signed off.

Elle Fanning’s Effie Trinket understands the practical side of the assignment. She knows that a dramatic entrance requires everybody to be standing in the right place before the dramatic entrance can happen. Her best scene involves persuading a reluctant participant to use the agreed door. There’s another door six feet away, and the participant keeps pointing at it. Effie explains that the agreed door is where the cameras are. It takes longer than it should.

The costumes are beautiful. More impressive is the apparent absence of anybody asking for an entirely different costume at 4:45 on the day of the broadcast. We hear about rebellion, but the real danger would be an email beginning ‘Quick thought on the look.’ The Capitol has built a civilization in which someone can select an outfit and expect it to remain selected.

Kieran Culkin’s Caesar Flickerman gets the job every event host secretly wants: a captive audience and a producer who can make the difficult guests sit down. He introduces each tribute with enough warmth to suggest genuine interest while leaving no doubt about the length of the segment. When an answer runs over, he smiles the smile of a man who has been told the catering staff start charging overtime at nine.

I wanted more of the sponsorship negotiations. One sponsor objects to the position of its logo on a water bottle. Another would like its name mentioned before a contestant drinks, even when the contestant is thirsty. Both requests strike me as manageable. The camera returns to Haymitch before we find out whether they were resolved. It’s an odd editorial choice in a film with so much money visibly riding on deliverables.

The sound design deserves praise for its attention to the unglamorous machinery of a large production. A microphone is tested twice. A cart rattles across a hard floor. Somewhere behind a very important speech, you can hear a folding table being opened. For a moment I thought we might follow that table to its destination, but another person began talking about freedom.

My friend Nessa Boyle, who books hotel conference rooms for a living, had a similar reaction. ‘Forty-eight arrivals, separate transport, a live broadcast, and nobody’s uncle turning up without a ticket,’ she said after the screening. ‘I’d like to see the budget before I judge these people.’ She was particularly impressed that the arena appeared to be ready when the guests arrived. Her last venue was still using a leaf blower.

The story loses focus once Haymitch begins testing the boundaries of the event. Every successful workaround creates a task for somebody else. It’s frustrating to watch a clever young man spend so much energy finding a gap in a system when he could simply tell the relevant coordinator where the gap is. I understand that he’s under strain. The coordinator is under strain too, and probably hasn’t eaten.

Sunrise on the Reaping is in theaters from November 20. Go for Fiennes, the scale of the production, and the rare pleasure of seeing a seating plan treated with appropriate gravity. If they make another one, I hope it’s about the debrief. I’d like to know who left the chairs out.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *