Town Hall Adds Adult Table For Residents Who Can Ask A Question
Applicants must reach a question mark without mentioning their driveway, their service record, or a photograph from 1986.
A town hall in Rivermere has introduced a separate adult table for residents who can ask a question without first explaining where they grew up, how long they’ve paid taxes, and what happened to the bakery that used to be opposite the library.
The table seats four and has remained mostly empty. Council staff say this should not be interpreted as a lack of public interest. More than 90 people registered for the meeting, including one man who brought a portable projector so he could explain his concern about the projector used at the previous meeting.
Entry to the adult table requires a resident to state the question in fewer than 40 words. A clerk reads it back, checks for a request that can receive an answer, and removes any sentence beginning my father always said. Successful applicants receive a chair, a glass of water, and the unusual experience of hearing a council official respond to the thing they actually asked.
The rule was proposed after resident Glenn Tabor used 14 minutes of public comment to establish that he owned a ladder. Tabor said the ladder was relevant to street lighting, though the connection was still several years away in the chronology he had prepared.
“My question was going to make perfect sense once you understood the kind of ladder,” Tabor said, standing beside a display of photographs arranged by rung. “Now they want us to ask things cold. It’s a very hostile way to run a community.”
Council clerk Saira Mendez says the table has already reduced confusion. During a trial, one woman asked when the pedestrian crossing would be repainted. An engineer said the crew was booked for the following month. The woman thanked him and sat down. Several audience members assumed she must know somebody on the council because the interaction had ended so efficiently.
Others felt the question lacked context. A retired accountant rose to explain that he had crossed that road in 1974 and remembered the paint being a different shade. Mendez directed him toward the regular microphone, where he joined a queue of residents preparing to describe all the places they had parked.
The distinction has proved especially difficult for people with statements disguised as questions. Staff have been instructed to listen past the phrase would you agree, because it is often followed by a speech the speaker intends to deliver regardless of the answer. Applicants who say their concern is really more of a comment will be given a larger room and a small kitchen timer that nobody expects to survive.
Mayor Colleen Pratt says the adult table is open to residents of every background. She rejected suggestions that the new arrangement favors the articulate. One successful applicant used six words. Another pointed to a photograph of a broken fence and asked whose job it was. Pratt said the difficulty was persuading people that an audience did not need their full employment history to understand a fence.
The council has hired a facilitator to help unsuccessful applicants. His first exercise asks residents to circle the part of their written submission that requires a response. He reports that most circle their own names. A smaller group circles the word outrageous and asks whether he needs it underlined as well.
At the latest meeting, the adult table’s only occupant was 62-year-old bus driver Imogen Lowe. She wanted to know whether the town planned to reopen the public restroom near the station. The council said yes, subject to a plumbing inspection. Lowe asked when the inspection would happen. The clerk confirmed a date. The exchange took 38 seconds.
It then took 23 minutes for the public gallery to finish explaining what public restrooms used to be like.
Tabor has formally appealed his exclusion. His submission includes a hand-drawn diagram, two pages about the decline of courtesy, and a photograph of the ladder in his previous garage. Mendez has returned it with a request that he attach a question. He says he will, but first there are some things she needs to understand about the garage.