Culture

HOA Orders Puddle To Match The Other Homes

The association has given the water 14 days to stop reflecting an unapproved house.

A neighborhood association representative examines a puddle in a suburban driveway.

The Willow Gables homeowners association has issued a violation to a puddle outside the home of Grant and Denise Wexler, giving the water 14 days to bring its appearance into line with neighboring properties.

The puddle currently reflects a blue sky, a bare maple tree, and part of a house that the architectural committee did not approve for use inside another homeowner’s puddle. Board president June Bell said the association had been patient while the water established itself.

“We’re all entitled to enjoy our homes,” Bell said. “But some of us paid a premium to live somewhere the ground doesn’t suddenly contain a second sky.”

The Wexlers received six photographs of the violation, including one taken at knee height that showed Bell’s own face in the water. That reflection has been referred to a separate committee because residents are prohibited from displaying portraits larger than 18 inches without permission.

The notice arrived in a plastic sleeve attached to the front door. Grant initially thought the issue was drainage. Bell explained that the drainage committee had already reviewed the puddle and found it acceptably wet. The current complaint concerned what the water was choosing to show people as they drove past.

Most of the surrounding homes are painted in approved shades of cream, taupe, and a gray the board describes as quiet. The puddle has displayed blue, white, and occasionally orange without submitting a single sample. At sunset, Bell counted at least five colors. The guidelines allow two, provided one is the trim.

Denise asked how the water could reflect the house in front of it without reflecting the sky above it. The architectural committee said homeowners were responsible for the appearance of all improvements on their lot, regardless of technical difficulties. A neighbor had managed to make a satellite dish resemble a small rock. The committee felt the Wexlers could show similar initiative.

Grant has offered to sweep the puddle into the street. The board rejected that proposal as an unauthorized transfer of a water feature to common property. He can apply for drainage approval once he provides a rendering of where the water intends to go.

He submitted a photograph of the storm drain. It was returned because the application required an artist’s impression. Grant drew an arrow from the puddle to the drain, but the arrow crossed a section of pavement maintained by the association. That requires a separate request and a deposit against damage caused by the arrow’s proposed route.

Denise says the couple initially considered waiting for evaporation, but the association has classified that as demolition. An approved contractor would need to stand nearby until the puddle was gone. He would also need to certify that the disappearance hadn’t affected any neighboring puddles, particularly the one outside Bell’s house, which has been grandfathered in as a pond.

“June’s water has ducks,” Grant said. “Ours has one leaf. We offered to get ducks, and she said that would make it worse.”

Bell confirmed that livestock couldn’t be used to correct an architectural violation. She also asked Grant to remove the leaf from the current application because its color changed after he submitted the photographs. The board can’t approve one version of a project and allow the owner to install another.

There is one affordable option. For a $75 review fee, the board will consider letting the Wexlers replace the reflection with a tasteful patch of beige. Grant obtained a paint sample, but the association said the proposed beige looked different when wet. A final decision will require a second sample shown under the conditions in which the puddle usually operates.

The couple has been invited to present their case at the next meeting. They’ll have three minutes, followed by questions from residents who have already emailed Bell to say they understand why standards matter. One has asked whether approving the puddle would allow other homeowners to install reflections of the same height.

Grant plans to explain that nobody installed the puddle. Denise has advised him to avoid that argument because the board might classify it as an unlicensed arrival. They’ve already paid a fee for a branch that fell onto the lawn without appearing on the planting schedule.

Rain is expected before the hearing. Bell has asked the couple to speak to whoever is handling that. She would prefer it to arrive after the meeting, when the board will have had a chance to decide which shade of water the neighborhood is prepared to accept.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *